Skip to main content

Stick it to Gary

NOTE: The following article was published on October 22. An update to this story appears below.

On October 9, 2023, the NHL put out an updated memo addressing on-ice special initiatives. The original memo from June suspended the use of themed warm-up jerseys associated with cancer-awareness, military appreciation, and most notably, LGBTQ+ pride nights. The updated memo in October took it a step further, banning the use of Pride Tape.

The story so far

This past April, seven players opted out of wearing rainbow-colored warm-up jerseys for Pride nights. For one of these players, his stated concern dealt with fear of legal retribution in his home country. For the rest, the reasonings were personal: Faith and family. Largely because of this dissent, Commissioner Gary Bettman and the league began re-evaluating these programs in the off-season. But at the time, he still seemed comfortable with these programs. Bettman had made Pride night detractors out to be the "distraction," and took satisfaction in the "aggressive and supportive" way the league had been promoting Pride nights, 

"This is one issue where players for a variety of reasons may not feel comfortable wearing the uniform as a form of endorsement, but I think that's become more of a distraction now, because the substance of what our teams and we have been doing and stand for is really being pushed to the side for what is a handful of players basically have made personal decisions, and you have to respect that as well." – Commissioner Bettman 

Becoming the distraction

By June, the tune had changed. No longer were the limited number of players opting out the distraction, Bettman declared that the warmup jerseys themselves were the distraction, all along.

"I've suggested that it would be appropriate for clubs not to change their jerseys in warmups because it's become a distraction and taking away from the fact that all of our clubs in some form or another host nights in honor of various groups or causes, and we rather those continue to get the appropriate attention that they deserve and not be a distraction." – Commissioner Bettman

Come October, and no less the day before the regular season began, the Pride Tape ban came down. Right when attention would have been on anticipation for the first games of the season. On the much-hyped draftee, Connor Bedard. On the Vegas Golden Knights beginning their quest to defend their champion status. On any of a number of storylines that resumed on October 10.

As a fan of baseball, I can't help but draw comparisons to how the Baltimore Orioles had stepped in it, themselves. In August, they temporarily suspended announcer Kevin Brown for truthfully pointing out that the team, until recently, had bad fortune in Tampa Bay. In suspending him, the narrative shifted from how great the Orioles team had become to how bad the Orioles organization was for silencing someone who was just telling it like it is. The NHL making a change like this within 24 hours of the season openers, likewise, took attention off the sport and onto the league, and for all the wrong reasons.

Why tape matters

In fairness to Bettman and the rest of the league, Pride night events taking place off-the-ice remain on-the-table. The league seems to have drawn the lines at what players bring to the bench and over the boards.

The difference with Pride Tape is that players, themselves, were making the decision to use it on the ice. Unlike warm-up jerseys, using Pride Tape was generally an opt-in means of showing support for the LGBTQ+ community. Banning themed warm-up jerseys took away the issue of players being coerced to show support for causes they do not, but banning Pride Tape took away the option for players to voluntarily do so.

The NHL has not purged references to Pride Tape from articles, yet. This leaves articles titled, "NHL's embrace of Pride Tape has meaningful, lasting impact" and "Pride Tape ingrained part of hockey culture, spreading to other sports" lingering on their servers, contradicting the league's own actions. The league's Community pages are littered with images of players using Pride Tape.

Play-to-rule

The NHL’s ban went unchallenged for a mere nine days, ending when Travis Dermott of the Arizona Coyotes broke the ice with a 3-inch wide stripe of Pride Tape on his stick in a game against Anaheim. Other players seem ready to defy the edict, as well, especially with pride nights later in the season. 

The league has said they will review Dermott’s use of stick tape “in due course,” but it’s a lose-lose scenario for the league. Taking action against Dermott may ultimately show what teeth the league has to enforce their late-breaking rule. If the league’s actions are weak, players may be willing to take the hit and stick it to Gary. On the other hand, a strong response may result in strong outcry from (more than seven) players, fans, the LGBTQ+ community, the NHLPA…

And really, the best action the league could take: Reversing course and not enforcing any ban. Officially, "adhesive tape of any color may be wrapped around the stick at any place for the purpose of reinforcement or to improve control of the puck." By playing with a type of tape the league doesn’t like, players essentially “play-to-rule,” as the actual, official, published rules give the league no grounds anyway.

The league wanted to ensure players are not forced to carry messaging they don’t believe in. Given that the league is an international entity with players of all types of backgrounds and worldviews, that’s understandable. But since players were already able to opt-out of wearing pride-themed warmup gear, reiterating that teams could not require players to wear it or to use Pride Tape could have and should have been the end of it. Instead, Gary Bettman and the league decided that the better way to handle a sticky situation was to step directly into it.

Update

On October 24, the NHL announced the following:
After consultation with the NHL Players' Association and the NHL Player Inclusion Coalition, Players will now have the option to voluntarily represent social causes with their stick tape throughout the season.

One can hope this is the end to the story: The NHL backing down from its own ill-considered last-minute rule.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Razing Arizona: Where does the NHL take the Coyotes?

Voters in Tempe closed the door on building a new arena to host the Arizona Coyotes. The team had already lost their lease to play at Desert Diamond Arena, requiring the team to work out the agreement to play at Arizona State University's Mullett Arena. At the end of the 2024-25 season, the Coyotes lose that option as well, which leaves them with the possibility of having to relocate, perhaps outside of Arizona. Right now, what the Coyotes need is an arena that's ready-built for the task of hosting the NHL, so where would that put them? (Note: Some arena capacities listed below are estimates, not official numbers.) Remain in Arizona, Desert Diamond Arena (Capacity: 17,125) Call it desperation, but I personally think that hockey in Arizona is not dead, yet. If the NHL and the Coyotes can work out an arrangement to come back to play at Desert Diamond Arena, it saves a lot of people a lot of heartache and headaches. My number one preference is the Coyotes to stay in Arizona, but I...

Let's Talk Shop (The 2024-25 Preseason Update)

Ladies, gentlemen, and everyone not already addressed: The NHL and MASL 2024-25 seasons are near at hand, and both The NHL MacGuffin and The MASL MacGuffin will soon be back up for grabs. Before we get deep into the season, I wanted to prepare fans of these projects for what's likely to be a tumultuous November and December... Not necessarily in terms of where The NHL and MASL MacGuffins travel, but in terms of what the life of this admin will be. And for a better understanding of that, I have to start with what happened last December. (Technically, I could go further, but I'll try to keep this all succinct.) At the end of December, a former boss of mine started messaging me asking what it would take for me to leave my current job and work for him, again. I gave him a number; he made it a reality. And through January (on either side of a trip to Las Vegas, no less), my former employer worked to find, hire, and train my replacement. In the meanwhile, my workload there doubled fo...