Voters in Tempe closed the door on building a new arena to host the Arizona Coyotes. The team had already lost their lease to play at Desert Diamond Arena, requiring the team to work out the agreement to play at Arizona State University's Mullett Arena. At the end of the 2024-25 season, the Coyotes lose that option as well, which leaves them with the possibility of having to relocate, perhaps outside of Arizona.
Right now, what the Coyotes need is an arena that's ready-built for the task of hosting the NHL, so where would that put them?
(Note: Some arena capacities listed below are estimates, not official numbers.)
Remain in Arizona, Desert Diamond Arena (Capacity: 17,125)
Call it desperation, but I personally think that hockey in Arizona is not dead, yet. If the NHL and the Coyotes can work out an arrangement to come back to play at Desert Diamond Arena, it saves a lot of people a lot of heartache and headaches. My number one preference is the Coyotes to stay in Arizona, but I'd call it a fool's hope at this point.
Houston, TX, Toyota Center (Capacity: 17,800)
The most talked-about option is Houston, and frankly: I get it. Texas, as a state, has bought big into the league with just one team, and it's a state big enough for at least two teams, just like in the NFL, NBA (where they have three), and the MLB. This move would put the Coyotes in one of the largest arenas in the west, and the branding still works in Texas. I'd be lying if I said I didn't think this was a good move, even if my love for baseball wishes nothing but karma on Houston.
Tulsa, OK, BOK Center (Capacity: 17,096)
This may be an odd choice, but the current home of the Tulsa Oilers may serve an NHL team well, probably better than even Oklahoma City. The catch is that a state as small in population as Oklahoma would end up having professional sports teams in two different cities, which may seem a little strange. That said, a similar model works with North Carolina, which has Charlotte and Raleigh hosting teams 2½ hours apart (versus Tulsa and OKC's 1½ hour difference).
Kansas City, MO, T-Mobile Center (Capacity: 17,544)
I don't know how Kansas City's T-Mobile Center (not to be confused with the T-Mobile Arena in Vegas) exists without an anchor tenant. They haven't hosted even an Arena Football League team since 2012, and its schedule boasts music tours and an annual college basketball tournament. Sure, the Scouts left Kansas City to become the Colorado Rockies and then the New Jersey Devils, but we're nearly 50 years removed from the early Expansion Era. Since then, this huge NHL-worthy arena has managed to sell out a preseason NHL game in about as neutral an arena as the Penguins and Kings could have had. The biggest catch would be proximity to the St. Louis Blues, as it was with the Scouts era.
New Orleans, LA, Smoothie King Center (Capacity: 16,900)
The last city I'm looking at that is in the general area of the Central Division with an arena of a capacity similar to Desert Diamond Arena is New Orleans. It's an odd pick, but the risk of spreading fans too thin is mitigated with the distance between New Orleans their nearest neighboring teams of Dallas, Nashville, and Tampa Bay. Perhaps the Big Easy could be a fresh market for the NHL.
Austin, TX, Moody Center (Capacity: 14,000)
Hear me out: Austin is currently the largest American city with no Big 4 professional sports team, but their MLS team draws in 20,000 fans on the regular. If there's demand for sports in Texas, it's in Austin. And while, yes, the largest arena in Austin that could host the team would be yet another college arena, this one may hold a less-shabby 14,000 fans while a permanent arena comes down the line. Of course, the prospect of having to get approval for a new arena would be a scary prospect for the NHL in light of what happened in Tempe...
Honorable Mentions: San Antonio, TX, AT&T Center (Capacity: 16,151); Milwaukee, WI, Fiserv Forum (Capacity: 15,178); Oklahoma City, OK, Paycom Center (Capacity: 15,152); and Salt Lake City, UT, Vivint Arena (Capacity: 14,000)
Several cities would be at least modest candidates for the NHL to relocate the Coyotes, but their existing arenas would keep the Coyotes at or near the smallest arena in the league. With these five, there's not a lot of good to say, but a fair amount negative. Strong cases have been made for other Texas cities, so San Antonio feels like an also-ran. Milwaukee would encroach on the Wild. Oklahoma City doesn't even have the largest arena in Oklahoma. Vivint Arena in Salt Lake City would be too small to give even to the Coyotes. All in all, a number of options that would only be good if nothing else good comes.
Portland, OR, Moda Center (Capacity: 18,280)
Now we get into the cities that might or would force a realignment, Portland being the leading among them. Personally, I like the idea of an Oregon ice hockey franchise, and maybe a minor bump between the Pacific and Central divisions wouldn't be so bad. The biggest draw for this idea is also the biggest risk: The Moda Center is the largest arena in the west not already hosting an NHL team, but that means there would need to be high demand to get those seats filled. That will be a challenge for a team that played as poorly as the Coyotes did this previous season.
California: Either Los Angeles, CA, Intuit Dome opening in 2024 (Capacity: 15,000), San Diego, CA, Pechanga Arena (Capacity: 12,920), or Sacramento, CA, Golden 1 Center (Capacity: 15,000)
The NHL already has two major markets in California covered: Los Angeles with with the LA Kings and the Anaheim Ducks and the San Francisco Bay Area with the San Jose Sharks. Diluting the Shark Tank with a team in Sacramento sounds awful considering you'd be doing so with a weak second option for hockey fans, and a third LA-area team would be doomed against fans of the Kings and the Ducks. While the state struggles to keep all of its five baseball teams, I doubt they'd be a way to make four hockey teams work.
Quebec, QC, Videotron Centre (Capacity: 18,259)
Quebec has had a history with the NHL up until 1995 when financial woes with the Nordiques sent them to Colorado. I have to count that against Quebec City, but what I have to count in favor of the city is boasting a ready-to-play 18,000+ seat hockey arena that has been successful while hosting a half-full arena for a junior team. I've got to honor that, but putting the NHL back into Quebec with a relocated Coyotes team seems a way to both doom the city and wreak havoc on the divisions. Personally, I'd be more inclined to see Quebec join the Atlantic Division as part of an expansion up to 36 teams alongside a TBD team in the Metropolitan, Tulsa in the Central, and Portland in the Pacific.
Hartford, CT, XL Center (Capacity: 14,750)
Realigning the divisions to put in Hartford would be no easy task, and the fact that you'd be looking at essentially a fourth New York metropolitan area team would be just a little bit absurd. Favoring Hartford is a quality arena for a team, but I think anyone who thinks that Hartford will return to the NHL soon is riding nostalgia too high.
Atlanta, GA, State Farm Arena (Capacity: 17,624)
Absolutely not! Atlanta has failed the NHL twice, already. While I could attribute many positive things said about Houston to Atlanta, moving the Coyotes to Atlanta runs the risk of being yet another 10-year proposition, and this move would require realigning the league to accommodate it. Come back to this when we have expansions up to a 36-team lineup, but even then, I'd be too afraid that the city would fool the NHL a third time.
Comments
Post a Comment